SOLVING CLIMATE | HUMANISTIC PERSPECTIVES FROM MIT
Anne McCants | Clues from climate change in history
How, in the nadir of the Little Ice Age, did the Dutch create a Golden Age?
During the Little Ice Age, the Dutch were a source of goods for other countries and sailed the largest merchant fleet in Europe.
"History shows that not everywhere fares equally poorly when faced with climatic stresses. Open-access societies — ones that tolerate a diversity of views and do not restrict agency to a preordained elite — have generally proved more innovative and resilient than less-open ones." For example, the 17th century Dutch Republic.
— Anne McCants, Professor of History, MacVicar Faculty Fellow
In this ongoing series, MIT faculty, students, and alumni in the humanistic fields share perspectives that are significant for solving climate change and mitigating its myriad social and ecological impacts. Anne McCants, an MIT professor of history, is a Margaret MacVicar Faculty Fellow, and Director of the MIT Concourse Program. Her research and teaching interests lie in the economic and social history of the Middle Ages and Early Modern Europe, as well as in the application of social science research methods across the disciplines. She is the president of the International Economic History Association. Here she describes what we can learn from human societies that managed to thrive in difficult climate conditions of the preindustrial past.
Q: There are many sensible approaches and ideas for addressing the climate crisis. Increasingly, it looks as if we’ll need all of them! What perspectives from economic history are valuable for addressing climate change and its impacts?
McCants: The present state of the climate suggests alarming prospects for the future, which is why it is reasonable to focus on mitigation strategies; we all naturally wish to ward off calamity.
Fortunately, the capacity for anticipation and planning are hallmarks of our success as a species. In essence, this capacity is the ability to learn from past experience. So, while human-induced climate change is not a challenge we have had to confront before, history can still offer us guidance. The prevailing climate has changed before, so we can consider those earlier impacts, both benevolent and dire. In the preindustrial past, warming generally brought benefits and colder periods hardship. Always, greater variability challenged human systems.
To take but one example from the last millennium, favorable global medieval climatic conditions deteriorated at the end of the 13th century, ushering in a long period of colder and more variable conditions (for both temperature and precipitation) that culminated in the so-called Little Ice Age. This lasted from the 16th century to the middle of the 19th century.
Historians have argued persuasively that such climate changes played an important role in many of the ecological and social disasters that punctuated this long period. That climate matters to human flourishing is without doubt; that the zone of beneficence is relatively narrow seems also to be the case. (Our present worry is for heat, but cold is no picnic either for a population reliant on agriculture to feed itself.) Appreciating our sensitivity to even narrow climate fluctuations is crucial, but it is only a first step.
Anne McCants, MIT Professor of History; photo by Richard Howard
"I find hope in the knowledge that when cooperation and openness have the edge over conflict and parochialism, formidable challenges can be met. In the case of the 17th C. Dutch, they were a society that cared about people in need. Nor did they find it shameful to achieve financial, and thereby social, success through hard work, ingenuity, and science. Importantly, everyone was entitled to have a go: immigrants, sons-of-laborers, and remarkably even women to a greater extent than anywhere else at the time."
Q. The Little Ice Age was a challenging time, with advancing glaciers, crop failures, and famine. But from your work, we understand that the Dutch fared much better than many other European societies during these centuries. Can you explain the reasons for their success?
McCants: History also shows that not everywhere fares equally poorly when faced with climatic stresses. Open-access societies — ones that tolerate a diversity of views and do not restrict agency to a preordained elite — have generally proved more innovative and resilient than less-open ones. The hardships of the 17th century at the nadir of the Little Ice Age were real enough, but while a wide range of social indicators stagnated or declined elsewhere, the Dutch Republic grew and prospered — resulting in the Dutch Golden Age. In 1673 the English ambassador to the Dutch Republic, Sir William Temple, noted that "Holland is a country where profit [is] more in request than honor."
And by profit, he did not mean avarice or greed, for he also recognized that "Charity seems to be very National among them." What he observed, as notably distinct from the aristocratic Europe of his birth, was a society that cared about people in need (funding orphanages, old-age homes, hospitals, and almshouses in abundance). Nor did they find it shameful to achieve financial, and thereby social, success through hard work (profit) and ingenuity (science). And, importantly, everyone was entitled to have a go: immigrants, sons-of-laborers, and remarkably even women to a greater extent than anywhere else at the time.
Detail: "Astronomer," by Gerard Dou, circa 1650-1655, Dutch, public domain
"Fortunately, the capacity for anticipation and planning are hallmarks of our success as a species. In essence, this capacity is the ability to learn from past experience. The prevailing climate has changed before, so we can consider those earlier impacts, both benevolent and dire."
Q: When you confront an issue as global and formidable as contemporary climate change, what gives you hope?
McCants: I find hope in the knowledge that when cooperation and openness have the edge over conflict and parochialism, formidable challenges can be met. History is no stranger to conflict, but as we move forward to address the risk now facing humanity, I hope we remember that cooperative and open-minded examples are also available, ripe for the learning.
For centuries, the Dutch have been masters at harnessing wind energy.
Note: Texts from Sir William Temple are from Book V and IV (respectively) of Observations upon the United Provinces of the Netherlands, 1673. Facsimile version available through Haithitrust from the University of Michigan.
Office of Dean Melissa Nobles
Series Editor/Designer: Emily Hiestand
Co-Editor: Kathryn O'Neill
Publication Associate: Alison Lanier
Detail: A river landscape with fishermen in rowing boats," by Abraham Storck, 1679; Dutch, public domain